Skip to content
Kurma Mariami
December 2, 2022

Why Single Women Date Married Guys

It is easy to guess an answer to the title. He is proven, he is safe, someone else has vouched for him. Those are guesses, though. Researchers have tested a version of the idea, under the name mate-choice copying, and what they found depends heavily on the conditions. This piece goes through those conditions one at a time.

Condition one: a real ring, in a real room

Of the five studies here, the closest test of the title comes from the Department of Zoology at Göteborg University. The team tested what they call the wedding ring effect, the idea that women would prefer men who are already engaged or married, in a series of live interactions between men and women. Women did not find men who signalled engagement, or who were seen as having a partner, more attractive or higher in socioeconomic status. The signs of engagement also made no difference to how willing the women said they were to have a short-term or long-term relationship with those men (Uller and Johansson, 2003).

So the plain version of the title failed the one live test among the studies here. The authors wrote that the result casts doubt on some simplified theories of human mate-choice copying.

Condition two: how many women came before

At James Cook University in Australia, 123 female students rated photos of men shown alone or with one, two or five women drawn as silhouettes. Each man was described to match: currently in a relationship, one, two or five past relationships, or none in the past four years. Men with one or two previous partners were generally rated more desirable than men with none. Men with five previous partners were rated less desirable. Younger women copied more than older women (Anderson and Surbey, 2014).

A history helped, then, but only up to a point. Five past partners counted against the man.

Condition three: the person doing the choosing

A study at East China Normal University turned the question around and looked at the model, the person whose choice is being watched. When a model accepted a target, the target's attractiveness rose more if the model had one or two past romantic experiences than if the model had none or many. The raters' own trust in other people made no significant difference on its own in the first study. In the second, it changed how much the model's history counted: for raters low or medium in interpersonal trust, the history mattered, and for raters high in trust, it had no effect (Zhou and colleagues, 2022).

A later study, with researchers from Qingdao, East China Normal and Fudan universities, asked whether it mattered which group the model belonged to. Women rated how willing they were to choose men, watched in-group or out-group female models accept, reject or stay undecided about those men, then rated again. Their ratings moved towards the models' choices. Acceptance copying was stronger than rejection copying, and it was discounted when the model came from an out-group (Xie and colleagues, 2023).

Condition four: what she knows about him

Two experiments at Sun Yat-Sen University in Guangzhou gave women more to go on than a photo. With only photos of potential partners, the women showed mate-choice copying. Once they had information about a man's personality traits or financial situation, positive or negative, the copying disappeared. That last effect showed up only for men of low attractiveness and for long-term partners (Liu and colleagues, 2021).

That is the opposite of how the title imagines things. In this study, knowing more about the man made other women's choices matter less.

Putting the conditions together

Across the five studies here, the only live test of a ring found no effect. In the other four, whether a target's rating moved depended on how many partners he was said to have had, the past romantic experience of the model shown choosing, the rater's own level of trust, whether the woman choosing was in-group or out-group, whether she accepted or rejected, and whether the rater knew anything about the man's character or money. The age of the rater mattered in one study, and the man's attractiveness and the kind of relationship mattered in another. None of the five measured why anyone chose as they did, and none showed single women favouring a man simply because he was married.

About the other kind of date

Mariami is also the name of a date. Mariami comes from Iran, and it is a dark, semi-dry, chewy date. Malaysia has no commercial date-growing trade, so every date sold here is imported.

Yellow and red fresh dates on a white background

An older version of this page linked to Kurma Bam Shah Alam, and that link stays. More about this site is on the about page and the contact page, and more articles are on the blog.