
These five junk food substitutes share one rule: each one replaces a snack, side or drink with something that counts as a portion of fruit or vegetables. The yardstick is the NHS page "5 A Day portion sizes", which says an adult portion of fruit or vegetables is 80g and then describes what that looks like for different foods, from strawberries to peas. Children are measured differently there: as a rough guide, a child's portion is the amount they can fit in the palm of their hand.
The nutrient figures below come from USDA FoodData Central (FDC), SR Legacy records last updated in 2019. Where a swap does not win on every number, the text says so.
1. A milk chocolate bar → 2 satsumas
The NHS lists "2 satsumas" as one portion of small fresh fruit. FDC has no record under the name satsuma, so the closest is "Tangerines, (mandarin oranges), raw" (record 169105), at 88g for a medium fruit. Two of them weigh 176g and come to about 93 kcal, 3.2g of fibre and 47mg of vitamin C.
A 44g milk chocolate bar (record 167587) comes to about 235 kcal and 8.1g of saturated fat, with 1.5g of fibre and no vitamin C. Sugar is the closer contest: the bar lists 22.7g of total sugars and the two mandarins 18.7g. The mandarins win clearly on calories, fat and fibre, but not by much on sugar.
2. A handful of sweets → 7 strawberries
Seven strawberries is the NHS example of a small-fruit portion. FDC weighs a medium strawberry at 12g (record 167762), so seven come to 84g, close to the 80g rule. That handful gives about 27 kcal, 4.1g of sugars, 1.7g of fibre and 49mg of vitamin C.
One ounce (28g) of hard sweets (record 167990) gives about 112 kcal and 17.8g of sugars, with no fibre and no vitamin C. The strawberries carry under a quarter of the sugars of the sweets.
3. A bag of crisps → 7 cherry tomatoes
Under salad vegetables the NHS lists 3 celery sticks, a 5cm piece of cucumber, 1 medium tomato or 7 cherry tomatoes. FDC's red ripe tomato record (170457) gives a cherry tomato as 17g, so seven weigh 119g: about 21 kcal and 6mg of sodium.
An ounce of plain salted potato crisps (record 169677) is about 151 kcal, 9.6g of fat and 149mg of sodium. If the crunch is the point, celery sticks or a piece of cucumber sit on the same NHS list.
4. A side of fries → a side of peas
This swap starts with an NHS rule about potatoes. The page says potatoes do not count towards your 5 A Day, because they are classed as a starchy food and usually take the place of bread, rice or pasta in a meal. A portion of fries is therefore not a vegetable portion at all. Cooked peas are: the NHS gives 3 heaped tablespoons of cooked vegetables such as carrots, peas or sweetcorn as one portion.
FDC lists a cup of frozen green peas, boiled and drained without salt (record 170017), at 80g, about 62 kcal and 4.1g of protein. A medium serving of fast-food fries (record 170698, 117g) comes to about 365 kcal and 17.2g of fat. The fries do carry more fibre in that serving, 4.4g against 3.6g for the peas, so this swap is about the calories and fat, and about adding a vegetable portion to the plate.
5. A can of cola → 1 orange
The NHS counts 1 apple, banana, pear, orange or nectarine as a portion of medium fresh fruit. FDC weighs one orange at 131g (record 169097): about 62 kcal, 12.3g of sugars and 3.1g of fibre. A 12 fl oz can of regular cola (record 174852, 370g) comes to about 155 kcal and 36.8g of sugars, with no fibre.
Squeezing the orange into a glass changes the rules. The page says unsweetened 100% fruit juice, vegetable juice and smoothies count as a maximum of 1 portion a day however much you drink, and that the combined total of these drinks shouldn't be more than 150ml a day, "which is a small glass". It also warns that drinks labelled "juice drink" are unlikely to count towards your 5 A Day and can be high in sugar.
Where dates fit
Dates come under the NHS dried fruit heading, where a portion is around 30g. The same section says dried fruit can be high in sugar, suggests swapping dried fruit for fresh fruit "especially between meals", and says it is best enjoyed as part of a meal, "as dessert, for example, not as a between-meal snack". So dates do not belong in the snack slot that the chocolate, sweets or crisps used to fill. They belong with a meal.
FDC has no record for Mariami dates, so the figures below are for Medjool (record 168191), a different variety. A 30g portion of Medjool comes to about 83 kcal, 20.0g of sugars and 2.0g of fibre, and one pitted Medjool weighs 24g in FDC. That is more sugar per portion than the two mandarins or the orange above.
For another set of five swaps, this time sorted with the NHS food label colours, read junk meals: five healthy and delicious substitutes. To see how fruit and vegetable portions fit into a full day, there is the daily healthy eating plan, and the wider picture is in the importance of healthy eating and the balanced diet.