
A lot of time can go into choosing a diet before any weight comes off. Low-fat or low-carb? More protein? The two randomised trials below put those choices side by side for a year or longer, and neither found a significant difference in weight between the diets it compared. If you want to lose weight fast, their results suggest spending less time on the choice and more on showing up, which one of them found strongly linked with weight loss.
Low-fat against low-carb for a year
The DIETFITS trial at Stanford randomly assigned 609 adults aged 18 to 50, with a BMI between 28 and 40, to a healthy low-fat diet or a healthy low-carbohydrate diet for 12 months (Gardner et al., 2018). Health educators ran 22 small-group sessions over the year, aimed at the lowest fat or carbohydrate intake each person could keep up long-term, with an emphasis on diet quality.
The two diets did end up different. At 12 months, carbohydrate supplied 48% of energy in the low-fat group and 30% in the low-carb group, and fat supplied 29% against 45%. Weight did not follow that gap. The low-fat group lost 5.3 kg and the low-carb group 6.0 kg, a difference the authors found was not significant. They also tested whether three genotype patterns, or a blood test taken 30 minutes after a glucose drink, were linked with how well each diet worked. Neither was.
Four diets, two years
An earlier trial in the United States went further, with 811 overweight adults randomly assigned to one of four reduced-calorie diets (Sacks et al., 2009). The targets ran from 20% fat, 15% protein and 65% carbohydrate at one end to 40% fat, 25% protein and 35% carbohydrate at the other. The diets used similar foods, and everyone was offered group and individual sessions for two years.
At 6 months, people on each diet had lost an average of 6 kg, or 7% of their starting weight. They began to regain after 12 months. By two years the losses sat between 2.9 and 3.6 kg in every comparison the trial made, with no significant difference. Satiety, hunger and satisfaction with the diet were similar on all four. The authors concluded that reduced-calorie diets give clinically meaningful weight loss whichever macronutrients they emphasise.
Tips the two trials point to
Pick the diet you can stand, and start. Neither trial found a winner among the mixes it tested. DIETFITS also checked two factors, genotype pattern and the glucose-drink blood test, and neither sorted people in advance. A diet you will still be eating in month nine is worth more than a better-looking plan you drop in week three.
Turn up. In the two-year trial, attendance at group sessions was strongly linked with weight loss, at 0.2 kg per session attended. The diet mixes themselves made no significant difference. If you are not in a programme, sharing your plan with someone you trust is on the NHS list of things to do (NHS, Tips to help you lose weight).
Know what "fast" looked like. The 6 kg in 6 months from the four-diet trial works out to roughly a quarter of a kilo a week, under the NHS target of 0.5 to 1 kg a week. The same NHS page lists "do not lose weight suddenly with diets" among the things to avoid.
Plan for month twelve. Regain started after a year in the four-diet trial, so the habits you build early, such as the plain swaps in five healthy substitutes for junk meals, have to last past the first exciting months.
Where dates sit in either diet
A date is almost all carbohydrate. In USDA FoodData Central, Medjool dates carry 75 g of carbohydrate and 0.15 g of fat per 100 g, and one pitted Medjool date weighs 24 g (FDC 168191). That one date comes to about 66 kcal and 18 g of carbohydrate. In DIETFITS, carbohydrate made up 48% of energy on the low-fat diet and 30% on the low-carb one, so a date leaves less room on the low-carb side. Count it like any other carbohydrate food.
The NHS counts a 30 g portion of dried fruit, dates included, as one of your 5 A Day, and asks that it be eaten at mealtimes rather than as a snack between meals, to reduce the impact on teeth (NHS, 5 A Day: what counts). For one way to spread portions across a whole day, see this daily healthy eating plan.
This article summarises published studies for general reading and is not medical advice.
More about this site is on the About Us page and the contact page.